I was a little hesitant to re-enter Madeline Black’s world after she grated on my nerves for the entire length of Black Wings. Don’t get me wrong, the world-building is well-done and the side characters are lovable but the heroine needs to grow up and act her age. For the first part of this book Maddy falls back into old habits but by the end she really pulls through and becomes the protagonist that I knew she was capable of being. I expect Black Howl to be truly kickass now that Miss Black has her act together!
Christina Henry expands upon an already amazing world by roping in the Fae and the werewolves. I didn’t expect to find my furry friends in a book about heaven and hell but I’ll take it! There’s a high level of political intrigue in Black Night and it plays an important role when Maddy is selected to be hell’s ambassador in the Faerie court. She gets thrown into the center of the supernatural world without knowing any of the rules and needless to say, she makes a few faux pas’. She unwittingly screws things up even more between Gabriel and herself which makes for an interesting cliff-hanger type ending. On a side note, when I first started reading this series I thought that a good chunk of the plot would revolve around Maddy’s responsibilities as an Agent of Death but that couldn’t be further from the truth. The story is still interesting but I can’t help but question Henry’s reasoning behind making her lead character a grim reaper that only collects the odd soul here and there.
The pacing is good and the action is plentiful but I found that the battles were lackluster. So much emphasis is placed on how “evil” and undefeatable the bad guys are and yet Maddy continues to plow through them with little to no resistance. Yes she gets hurt but for me, it seemed like she was able to vanquish her enemies too easily and not with the help of her mad skills either but with sheer dumb luck. I think that Christina’s goal was to have a constant sense of fear floating in the air but it just wasn’t believable. After a while the whole thing felt repetitive and predictable.
For the most part, Gabriel was absent from this story which made me happy, that is, up until Maddy started wishing he was by her side at every turn. This neediness annoyed me more than anything else. Plus they still barely even know each other so how can she be head over heels in love with this guy? I liked how Henry ended this book with regards to these two and look forward to seeing how she handles it in the next installment. This aspect of the story has the potential to make or break this series in my opinion.
The story has been vastly improved upon in this second installment but it’s still not quite *there* yet. I’m hoping this series will continue in its upward trajectory and that all of the glitches will be ironed out in Black Howl otherwise I might make it my final stop on this ride. I enjoyed the political play in Black Night but I found it hard to get past the unrealistic battles and Maddy’s ridiculous relationship with Gabriel.
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Recommendation: | For fans of Heaven/Hell mythology, dark humor and those who prefer their romantic content to be G-rated. |
Like this, like that: | Alex Craft series by Kalayna Price, Dark Angels series by Keri Arthur and the Grigori Legacy series by Linda Poitevin. |
About the Blogger
I review Urban Fantasy and Paranormal Romance books with a focus all things werewolf. Based out of Ottawa, Canada
I hope it will improve for you I Have the third to read too. I really enjoyed this one so I’m cute curious I’m sorry it didn’t blow your mind away.
@Melliane Every book we read can’t always be good (unfortunately). This one wasn’t terrible but it didn’t knock my socks off either.